Adjusting Estate Plan Documents for Lifetime Gifts or Loans

Clients are often concerned with ensuring that they treat each of their children equally. Clients worry that imbalanced gifting between children, for example providing more funds to one child to attend a private university while their sibling attended a state school, providing one child with the funds to assist with the down payment on a house, or assisting one child with launching a business, will cause tension if not balanced out in the long run. This concern leads to a discussion about which children previously received gifts or loans from the parents and how to adjust the distribution of trust assets to children to be fair to siblings who did not receive such gifts and loans.

One of my favorite phrases with clients is "the only limitation on what you can do is your imagination." I have one client who has chosen to add a provision to his trust that states that all distributions to children whether as a loan or a gift are to be treated as a gift and shares of the children are specifically not to be adjusted for anything received during lifetime. Other clients want options that provide greater equality, but are more complex. While I am happy to provide those options, I will often suggest to a client he or she may want to consider what is "fair" for each child rather than what is "equal.”

There are a number of ways to adjust distributions to account for gifts or loans to children during the client’s lifetime. One example is to have the trustee add all loans and/or gifts made during the client’s lifetime back into the estate at death for calculation purposes. The trustee then provides an equal division for all children, adjusting each child's share for loans and/or gifts they received during lifetime. If clients elect to use this method to adjust bequests, careful records should be kept, to ensure that children are not penalized for loans that were previously repaid.

Another option is to provide a specific dollar amount for each of the children who did not receive loans or gifts during lifetime, which the trustee distributes from the estate before the equal division occurs. Again, good record keeping is important with this method to avoid creating an imbalance in favor of a different child.

There are number of other options, but it is clear that such clauses should be added to a client's documents only after a discussion with the client and careful drafting by a qualified professional.

Alan Ferrara

What's the Difference between Living Wills & Living Trusts?

     A common problem clients have when starting the estate planning process is confusion regarding the purpose of the various documents involved in an estate plan. Legislatures and attorneys augment this confusion by using similar common names for some of the documents. When you have a Will, a Living Trust, and a Living Will, a measure of uncertainty is understandable from clients who do not deal with these documents on a daily basis.

     We have discussed in detail how a Will dictates the decedent's desires regarding property held in their name alone the death, that must pass through the Probate Court before passing to their heirs. Similarly, we have addressed how a Living Trust administers property held in the name of the Living Trust, and deals with many of the same issues, but does so outside of the Probate Process. Today's post addresses the Living Will, what it does, and how it fits into an estate plan., A Living Will deals with what we refer to as the "here and now" . Together with the Patient Advocate Designation, the Living Will helps to address health care issues that arise during a client’s lifetime where, due to incapacity, the client is unable to make medical decisions for themselves.

     When executing a Patient Advocate Designation, clients nominate an individual to make medical decisions on their behalf if they are incapacitated and unable to make those decisions for themselves. A Living Will acts as an instruction manual from the client to their designated patient advocate, stating their wishes to that advocate regarding their healthcare. The choice to have a Living Will is purely voluntary and the Living Will may be as specific or as general about health care wishes as the client prefers. Under Michigan law a Living Will has no legal force. However, if there is a conflict regarding an incapacitated person's care that necessitates Probate Court involvement, written or oral statements, such as a Living Will, are admissible as evidence of the incapacitated persons desires as to their own care.

     The basic Living Will addresses the client’s desires concerning the use of medical devices to artificially prolong their lives. It is our belief that regardless of the client’s other desires regarding health care, it is important the client articulates an opinion regarding their desires for continued care if their lives are being maintained solely by machines. If clients wish to include more expansive directions to their patient advocate, we ask them to provide us with a list of those instructions for inclusion in their Living Will and encourage them to speak with their designated patient advocate so that everyone involved is on the same page regarding care.

     While contemplating our mortality is an uncomfortable topic for almost everyone, some solace can be gained by knowing that those people who we trust to make decisions on our behalf are guided in those decisions by our own instructions.

Matt Ferrara